In Immigration News

Denied — and Now in Immigration Court? What Actually Happens

Other languages: Türkçe

A denial letter is frightening. A Notice to Appear that follows it is more frightening still, because it means immigration court. But court is not deportation, and on one common type of family case the government — not you — has to prove its position. That single fact changes how these cases are fought.

In brief
What an NTA is
The charging document that starts removal proceedings in immigration court. It is a summons, not a deportation order.
Why a denial can trigger one
Under USCIS policy PM-602-0187, in force since 28 February 2025, USCIS generally issues an NTA when an application is denied and the person has no other lawful status.
On an I-751, it is automatic
When conditional residence is terminated, the regulation says the director shall issue a notice to appear. It is not discretionary (8 CFR 216.4, 216.5).
The fact in your favour
On a terminated I-751, the burden of proof is on the government, by a preponderance of the evidence — not on you.
Court is a second look
You may submit evidence to rebut the denial. An immigration judge sees the case fresh.

How a green card case turns into a court case

There are two routes and they feel the same from the outside, but they work differently.

Discretionary NTA Mandatory NTA
When it happens A denial that leaves you without lawful status — I-485, I-539 and others Termination of conditional resident status on an I-751 or I-829
Where the rule lives USCIS policy memorandum PM-602-0187 (28 February 2025) 8 CFR 216.4 and 216.5 — the director shall issue one
Can it be avoided Sometimes. Keeping or regaining lawful status is the lever Not by argument. The route is to undo the termination itself
Who proves the case in court You do, on whatever relief you apply for The government does, on the termination

The first is discretionary. USCIS policy since 28 February 2025 has been to issue a Notice to Appear when it denies an application and the person is left without lawful status — the agency described itself as generally defaulting toward issuing them, and reported more than 26,700 removal cases started in roughly the first three months.

The second is not discretionary at all. If your conditional residence is terminated, the regulation is written in the imperative: in addition to the notice of termination, the director shall issue a notice to appear. Nobody decided to send you to court. The rule did.

The part nobody tells you: who has to prove what

In most immigration applications, the burden sits on you. You file, you prove, you lose if the evidence is thin.

A terminated I-751 is the exception, and it is a large one. The regulation says that during the ensuing removal proceedings the person may submit evidence to rebut the determination, and that the burden of proof shall be on the Service to establish, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the grounds for termination are true.

Most people walk into that courtroom believing they have to prove their marriage was real. On a terminated I-751, the government has to prove it was not.

That is a genuinely different posture. The government has to stand up and show the marriage was not entered into in good faith. You are answering a case, not building one from nothing. Clients hear “court” and assume the worst position possible; on this particular filing it is close to the opposite.

The route back that closes quietly

There is a door here that shuts, and almost nobody knows the timing of it.

If a joint I-751 is filed before jurisdiction vests with the immigration judge, and the director excuses the late filing and approves it, the director restores permanent residence, removes the conditional basis and cancels the outstanding notice to appear. The court case disappears.

File after jurisdiction has vested and the mechanism changes: the immigration judge may terminate the matter, but only on a joint motion — which means the government has to agree. Same filing, materially worse position, decided by nothing more than timing.

Three things that make a court case worse

Missing the hearing. An order can be entered in your absence, and undoing one is far harder than attending. If you have moved, file the change of address — a notice sent to the old address still counts as notice.

Waiting to see what happens. The window to file before jurisdiction vests is short and it is the best position you will have. Delay converts a filing you control into one that needs the government’s agreement.

Treating the NTA as the end. It is the start of a process in which you have rights, including the right to counsel at your own expense, and on a terminated I-751 the lighter end of the burden.

What to do in the first week

  • Read the date and location on the notice first. Everything else is secondary to not missing a hearing.
  • Keep the denial letter. It states the grounds, and the grounds are what the government has to prove.
  • File the change of address if anything has changed. This is the single most common avoidable loss in immigration practice.
  • Work out whether a filing can still be made before jurisdiction vests. This is time-sensitive and worth a same-week conversation.
  • Do not leave the country to “reset” things. Departing while proceedings are pending can create consequences far worse than the proceedings.

If the denial was of a petition to remove conditions, our page on Form I-751 and the 90-day window explains the filing the court case grew out of, and the four waiver routes cover filing without a spouse’s signature.

Frequently asked questions

Does a Notice to Appear mean I am being deported?

No. It is the document that starts a case in immigration court. It is closer to a summons than a judgment. You have the right to appear, to be represented at your own expense, and to apply for whatever relief fits your situation. Many people who receive an NTA are not removed.

Why did USCIS send me to court instead of just denying my case?

Since 28 February 2025, USCIS policy PM-602-0187 has been to issue a Notice to Appear when it denies an application and the person is left with no lawful status. On an I-751 it is not a policy choice at all: when conditional residence is terminated, the regulation says the director shall issue a notice to appear.

Who has to prove the marriage was real in court?

On a terminated I-751, the government does. The regulation places the burden of proof on the Service to establish, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the grounds for termination are true, and it expressly allows you to submit evidence to rebut the determination. This is unusual and it is a real advantage.

Can my case be taken out of court?

Sometimes. If a joint petition is filed before jurisdiction vests with the immigration judge and the director excuses the late filing and approves it, the regulation provides for restoring status and cancelling the notice to appear. After jurisdiction vests, an immigration judge may terminate the matter, but only on a joint motion, which requires the government to agree.

Can I still work while the case is in court?

It depends on what your work authorisation rests on, and a termination of conditional residence takes effect on the date of the director’s determination. This is one of the first things to check rather than assume, because the answer drives decisions about your job in the same weeks you are dealing with the notice itself.

Contact

Ozek Law Firm, LLC · Tolga Ozek, Attorney at Law
4500 East West Highway, Suite 150, Bethesda, MD 20814
+1 (202) 854-8545 · info@ozeklaw.com · ozeklaw.com/contact

About the author
Tolga Ozek, Esq.

Tolga Ozek is the founder of Ozek Law Firm, LLC in Bethesda, Maryland. He is admitted in Maryland, New York and the District of Columbia, and in Texas on inactive status. His practice covers family-based immigration, conditional residence and removal defence.

Have you received a Notice to Appear?

We read the notice, work out whether the case can still be taken out of court, and tell you plainly where the burden actually sits. In English or Turkish.

Talk to us this week


This page is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Attorney Advertising. It reflects INA 216(c)(4) (8 U.S.C. 1186a(c)(4)), 8 CFR 216.4, 8 CFR 216.5, 8 CFR 106.2 and USCIS policy memorandum PM-602-0187 (28 February 2025) as in force on October 22, 2026. Fees, form editions and agency practice change. Confirm current requirements at uscis.gov before filing. No attorney can guarantee an outcome.

Ozek Law Firm, LLC · 4500 East West Highway, Ste 150, Bethesda, MD 20814 · +1 (202) 854-8545 · info@ozeklaw.com · www.ozeklaw.com
Licensed in Maryland, New York and Washington, D.C.; federal immigration practice across the United States. Consultations in English, Turkish, Spanish, Arabic, Russian and Chinese.

Tolga Ozek

Tolga Ozek is the founder of Ozek Law Firm, LLC in Bethesda, Maryland. His practice covers U.S. immigration and business law, including investor and intracompany-transfer visas, employment-based immigration, family-based green cards and naturalization. Licensed in Maryland, New York and the District of Columbia; also admitted in Texas (inactive). The firm advises clients in English, Turkish and Spanish.